On the other hand, other States believe that the costs associated
with arbitration may be lower than expected owing to the limited number of cases that may go
to arbitration and the ability to structure an efficient arbitration process and to put a cap on the
compensation of arbitrators (e.g. as is sometimes done with the last-best-offer form of
arbitration).
(...) Within two
months of the last appointment, the two appointed arbitrators shall appoint the third arbitrator,
who shall act as the “Chair”. (...) However, the Model Commentaries differ in situations where there is no appointment,
either by the competent authorities for the first two arbitrators or by the arbitrators for the third
arbitrator.
Language:English
Score: 1205242.3
-
https://www.un.org/development...%3AC.18%3A2019%3ACRP%20.18.pdf
Data Source: un
If within thirty (30) days of the request for arbitration either party has not appointed an arbitrator, or if within fifteen (15) days of the appointment of two arbitrators the third arbitrator has not been appointed, either party may request the President of the International Court of Justice to appoint an arbitrator. The procedure for the arbitration shall be fixed by the arbitrators, and the expenses of the arbitration shall be borne by the parties as assessed by the arbitrators. (...) The parties shall be bound by any arbitration award rendered as a result of such arbitration as the final adjudication of any such dispute, controversy, or claim.
15.
Language:English
Score: 1184797.7
-
https://unpan.un.org/sites/unp...able%20Development%20Goals.pdf
Data Source: un
The decisions of the arbitral tribunal shall be based on general principles of international commercial law. (...) The arbitral tribunal shall have no authority to award punitive damages. (...) The Parties shall be bound by any arbitration award rendered as a result of such arbitration as the final adjudication of any such dispute, controversy, or claim.
8.
Language:English
Score: 1125455
-
https://publicadministration.u...ublications/content/terms.html
Data Source: un
That section briefly describes the structure and operation of an arbitration procedure, including how a purely domestic arbitration procedure differs from the mutual agreement procedure
6
arbitration procedure found in some bilateral income tax treaties. (...) It is also possible that quasi-judicial tribunals and arbitrators are prevented from addressing arguments related to human or procedural rights.
(...) For instance, where domestic arbitration of tax cases is allowed, it will be necessary to determine whether an arbitrator has jurisdiction to determine his own jurisdiction in a specific case and whether any such decision may be subject to judicial review.
Language:English
Score: 1092011.5
-
https://www.un.org/development...3/E%3AC.18%3A2019%3ACRP.17.pdf
Data Source: un
An arbitration tribunal shall consist of three arbitrators or of a sole arbitrator as agreed by the parties.
(...) Arbitrators selected by the parties or appointed by the court may be arbitrators listed in the lists of arbitrators of the arbitration centres in Vietnam or may be other arbitrators.
5. (...) The replacement of an arbitrator shall be decided by the other arbitrators in the arbitration tribunal.
Language:English
Score: 1036287.3
-
https://www.wto.org/english/th...c_e/vnm_e/WTACCVNM28_LEG_6.pdf
Data Source: un
UN Commentary, Article 25, paragraph 4, sets forth the
pros and cons of arbitration from the perspective of
developing countries
The decision of each country as to whether or not to
include an arbitration provision in its treaties should be
based on policy and administrative considerations and
its actual experience with MAP
2
2
For countries who do not wish to include mandatory
arbitration in their treaties, UN Commentary, paragraph
14 provides a “voluntary” arbitration provision
Under voluntary arbitration, a case can go to
arbitration if BOTH CAs and the TP agree to submit the
case
– Since both CAs must agree to submit the case, this approach
gives less assurance than mandatory arbitration that a MAP will be
produced
In addition, it would be possible to provide for
arbitration on a case-by-case basis through a special
MAP
3
“Voluntary” versus “Mandatory” Arbitration
Differences between OECD and UN Arbitration articles
Under the OECD provision, arbitration can begin if
the case has not been resolved within two years of
the presentation of the case; the UN provision uses a
three year period
Under the OECD provision, it is the taxpayer who
can require that the case be submitted to arbitration
regardless of the views of the CAs. (...) This form of arbitration limits
the arbitrators to choosing between the two “last best
offers” by the two CAs. The Arbitrators simply pick one
or the other offer (and give no opinion or justification for
the decision)
The CAs can nonetheless choose to have an independent
and reasoned arbitration opinion if they wish
7
“Last Best Offer” form of Arbitration
Basic features of the UN Arbitration provision
Terms of Reference
– The CAs shall establish the Terms of Reference (“TR”) which set
forth the questions to be resolved by the arbitral panel
– The TR must be established within three months of the request for
arbitration
Selection of Arbitrators
– Each CA selects an arbitrator and the two selected chose a Chair
8
5
Basic features of the UN Arbitration provision
Selection of Arbitrators (cont.)
– If no third arbitrator is selected within three months, the Chair of
the UN Committee of Experts shall select the third arbitrator
– Rules are set forth for compensation of arbitrators
– Arbitrators must establish their independence and impartiality
9
Basic features of the UN Arbitration provision
Procedural and Evidentiary Rules
– To the extent not set forth in the Terms of Reference, procedural
rules shall be adopted by the arbitrators
Costs
– In general, each party bears the costs of its participation
• Cost of the meetings and administration are borne by the CA to whom
the case was presented
10
6
Basic features of the UN Arbitration provision
Independent opinion approach
– If the CAs so choose, the arbitrators may reach their own decision
on the case
– The opinion must indicate the sources of law relied on and the
reasoning of the decision
– With the parties’ permission, an edited version of the opinion may
be published
• The published opinion has no precedential value as such but may be
useful in increasing international awareness of existing practices
11
Developments with respect to Arbitration
A number of bilateral treaties have some form of
mandatory arbitration provision
Some treaties have no current arbitration provision but
require that if the treaty partner enters into a treaty with
an arbitration provision, it must reopen the issue with
the country
In the Final Report on BEPS Action 14, 20 countries
committed to mandatory binding arbitration to be
developed under the proposed Multilateral Instrument.
Language:English
Score: 1035082
-
https://www.un.org/esa/ffd/wp-...xTreaties_Arbitration_Ault.pdf
Data Source: un
The arbitration procedures provided for by the EU Arbitration Convention and the model arbitration provision are both mandatory.
(...) How does a MAP case get into arbitration?
Under the model arbitration provision, there are three requirements to trigger the arbitration procedure:
1. (...) The model arbitration provision provides for two alternative processes a general process and a streamlined arbitration process:
• General arbitration process.
Language:English
Score: 1033045.8
-
https://www.un.org/esa/ffd/wp-...014/10/4STM_EC18_2008_CRP6.pdf
Data Source: un
COMPOSITION OF THE ARBITRATION BODY
9. The arbitration body shall consist of three arbitrators, unless the Parties agree to a different uneven number.
10. (...) Where a Party to an arbitration is a developing country Member, the arbitration body shall, if the developing country Member so requests, include at least one arbitrator from a developing country Member.
(...) A Third Party may not participate in the selection of arbitrators or in the establishment of the arbitration body's working procedures.
Language:English
Score: 1032718.6
-
https://www.wto.org/english/news_e/news98_e/scm19.htm
Data Source: un
The arbitral tribunal shall consist of [a sole arbitrator]. The place of arbitration shall be [ ]. The language to be used in the arbitral proceedings shall be [ ]. (...) The arbitral tribunal shall consist of [a sole arbitrator] [three arbitrators].
Language:English
Score: 1032348.6
-
https://www.itu.int/ITU-D/fina...a-11/pdf/presentation_WIPO.pdf
Data Source: un
THE LAW OF ARBITRATION
THE LAW OF ARBITRATION
Royal Decree No. (...) An arbitrator may not be challenged from judgment save for reasons that
occur or appear after filing the arbitration instrument.
(...) ARTICLE 14:
Where an arbitrator is appointed in place of a dismissed or a withdrawing
arbitrator, the date fixed for the award shall be extended by thirty days.
Language:English
Score: 1032348.6
-
https://www.wto.org/english/th...c_e/sau_e/WTACCSAU59_LEG_4.pdf
Data Source: un